Fashioned Custard Pie

A slice of old-fashioned custard pie is pure comfort. Silky filling, warm vanilla, a little nutmeg on top, and a flaky crust that shatters just a bit when you cut in.

Jump To Recipe Pin Recipe

This is the kind of pie that looks simple on purpose. No fancy layers. No piles of toppings. Just a smooth, creamy custard baked until it’s set around the edges with a gentle wobble in the middle.

And yes, it’s one of those desserts that tastes even better after it’s been chilled for a few hours. The texture turns dreamy. The flavor settles in. The whole pie slices cleanly, like it’s been waiting patiently for you.

If you’ve ever had a custard pie that turned out watery, weepy, or cracked on top, don’t worry. This recipe is built to help you avoid all of that. A few small moves make all the difference, and I’ll walk you through every one.

WHAT IS AN OLD-FASHIONED CUSTARD PIE?

A classic custard pie is a baked egg custard poured into a pie crust and cooked low and slow until it’s set.

The filling is usually made from:

• eggs

• milk (sometimes cream or half-and-half, too)

• sugar

• vanilla

• a pinch of salt

• nutmeg on top

That’s it. The eggs thicken the custard as it bakes, turning a simple liquid mixture into that soft, sliceable filling.

The tricky part? Custard has a narrow comfort zone. Bake it too long or too hot and it can curdle, crack, or turn grainy. Bake it too little and the center stays loose and can seep into the crust.

The sweet spot is completely doable at home. You just need the right temperature, a gentle hand, and a good “doneness” check.

YOU WILL LOVE THIS OLD-FASHIONED CUSTARD PIE

CREAMY, SMOOTH TEXTURE: The filling bakes up silky and tender, not rubbery or spongy.

OLD-SCHOOL FLAVOR: Vanilla and nutmeg keep it classic and cozy.

SIMPLE INGREDIENTS: Nothing fancy. The pantry and fridge do most of the work.

MAKE-AHEAD FRIENDLY: This pie actually prefers a chill in the fridge, which makes it a great dessert to prep early.

EASY TO DRESS UP: Serve it plain, add a little whipped cream, or scatter fresh berries on the plate. It fits right in.

OLD-FASHIONED CUSTARD PIE INGREDIENTS

Every ingredient matters here. Custard is simple, so the details show.

You’ll need:

For the crust

• 1 (9-inch) unbaked pie crust (homemade or refrigerated)

• 1 egg white (optional, for brushing the crust)

For the custard filling

• 4 large eggs

• ¾ cup granulated sugar

• 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour (or cornstarch)

• ¼ teaspoon fine salt

• 2½ cups whole milk

• ½ cup heavy cream (or use more whole milk)

• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract

• ¼ to ½ teaspoon ground nutmeg (for the top)

Why these ingredients work

Eggs: They’re the structure. They thicken the filling as it bakes and give custard that soft “set” texture.

Whole milk + a little cream: Whole milk keeps the custard creamy. A splash of cream adds extra richness and helps the filling feel lush without being heavy.

Flour (or cornstarch): Not every custard pie uses it, but a small amount adds stability and helps guard against weeping. It’s a quiet helper.

Vanilla: The main flavor. Use pure vanilla if you can—custard doesn’t have many ingredients, so it shines.

Nutmeg: That signature top note. It smells like a bakery when it hits the warm custard.

OUR RECIPE DEVELOPER SAYS
Freshly grated nutmeg gives the best flavor, but ground nutmeg works beautifully and keeps this recipe weeknight-easy.

INGREDIENT SUBSTITUTIONS AND ADDITIONS

Custard pie is flexible, as long as you keep the egg-to-liquid balance steady.

DAIRY OPTIONS:

• Use half-and-half instead of milk + cream (use 3 cups total).

• Evaporated milk works too and gives a slightly deeper dairy flavor. Use 3 cups evaporated milk in place of the milk and cream.

SUGAR SWAPS:

• Replace ¼ cup of the granulated sugar with light brown sugar for a warmer, almost caramel-like flavor.

SPICE OPTIONS:

• Add a pinch of cinnamon to the custard mixture.

• Or use a tiny pinch of ground cloves (tiny is the key—cloves can take over fast).

CITRUS TWIST:

• Add 1 teaspoon of lemon zest to brighten everything up. It’s subtle and really nice with vanilla.

TOPPING IDEAS:

• Lightly sweetened whipped cream

• Fresh berries

• A dusting of powdered sugar (right before serving)

THE CRUST MATTERS MORE THAN YOU THINK

A custard filling is basically a liquid at the start. If the crust isn’t ready for it, you can end up with a soggy bottom.

That’s why this recipe uses a quick partial bake (also called blind baking). It helps the crust set and start crisping before the custard goes in.

PRO TIP:
If you’re using a refrigerated pie crust, let it sit at room temperature for about 10 minutes so it unrolls without cracking.

Egg white trick (optional, but helpful)

Brushing the warm crust with a thin layer of egg white creates a light barrier that helps keep the bottom crust flaky.

It takes 10 seconds and is worth it if you’ve ever battled a soft crust.

HOW TO MAKE OLD-FASHIONED CUSTARD PIE

Plan for chill time. The bake is straightforward, but the custard needs time to fully set after it comes out of the oven.

STEP ONE: Preheat the oven

Preheat the oven to 375°F for the crust.

Place a baking sheet on the middle rack. Baking the pie on a sheet makes it easier to move and catches any drips.

STEP TWO: Prepare the pie crust

Fit the crust into a 9-inch pie plate. Crimp the edges.

Chill the crust for 10 to 15 minutes in the fridge. This helps it hold its shape while baking.

STEP THREE: Partially bake the crust

Line the crust with parchment paper or foil, then fill with pie weights or dry beans.

Bake for 12 to 14 minutes.

Carefully remove the parchment and weights, then bake for 5 to 7 minutes more, just until the bottom looks dry and lightly set.

OUR RECIPE DEVELOPER SAYS
If your crust puffs up after you remove the weights, gently press it down with the back of a spoon while it’s still warm.

STEP FOUR: Optional egg white barrier

If using, lightly brush the warm crust with egg white.

Set the crust aside while you make the filling.

STEP FIVE: Lower the oven temperature

Reduce the oven to 325°F. Custard likes gentle heat.

STEP SIX: Mix the custard base

In a large bowl, whisk together:

• eggs

• sugar

• flour (or cornstarch)

• salt

Whisk until smooth and slightly lighter in color.

STEP SEVEN: Warm the milk

Warm the milk and cream in a saucepan over medium heat until it’s steamy and hot but not boiling.

You’re looking for tiny bubbles around the edges, not a rolling boil.

STEP EIGHT: Temper the eggs

Slowly pour about ½ cup of the warm milk mixture into the egg mixture while whisking constantly.

Then slowly whisk in the rest.

This step keeps the eggs from scrambling and helps you get a perfectly smooth custard.

STEP NINE: Add vanilla and strain (yes, strain)

Stir in the vanilla.

Then pour the custard through a fine-mesh strainer into a clean bowl or large measuring cup.

PRO TIP:
Straining takes one minute and helps guarantee a silky texture. It catches any tiny bits of egg or flour that didn’t fully blend.

STEP TEN: Fill the crust and bake

Pour the custard into the partially baked crust.

Sprinkle nutmeg evenly over the top.

Bake at 325°F for 35 to 45 minutes, until the edges are set and the center still has a gentle jiggle.

If the crust edges start browning too quickly, cover them with foil or a pie shield.

STEP ELEVEN: Cool, then chill

Cool the pie on a wire rack for at least 1 hour.

Then refrigerate for at least 4 hours (overnight is even better) before slicing.

This is where the magic happens—custard firms up as it chills.

HOW TO TELL WHEN CUSTARD PIE IS DONE

This part is the difference between silky custard and a pie that cracks.

Here’s what you want:

• The edges look set and slightly puffed.

• The center (about a 3-inch circle) wobbles gently when you nudge the pie plate.

• The top looks glossy, not wet.

If you like using a thermometer, aim for 170°F to 175°F in the center. Once it climbs past that, custard can tighten up fast.

PRO TIP:
Custard continues cooking from residual heat after you pull it out. If you wait until the center is completely firm in the oven, it can end up overbaked.

TROUBLESHOOTING THIS CUSTARD PIE

Old-Fashioned Custard Pie

Old Fashioned Custard Pie recipe that actually sets perfectly every time. This version uses simple pantry ingredients like eggs, whole milk, and nutmeg for a silky finish. It is a classic vintage dessert that tastes amazing chilled. Perfect for when you need a simple sweet treat without a lot of fuss.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 20 minutes mins

Cook Time 45 minutes mins

Total Time 1 hour hr 5 minutes mins

Course Pie

Cuisine American

Servings 8

Ingredients

  

1x2x3x

For the crust

• 1 9-inch unbaked pie crust
• 1 egg white optional

For the custard

• 4 large eggs
• ¾ cup granulated sugar
• 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour or cornstarch
• ¼ teaspoon fine salt
• 2½ cups whole milk
• ½ cup heavy cream or more whole milk
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
• ¼ to ½ teaspoon ground nutmeg for topping

Instructions

 

• Preheat the oven to 375°F. Fit the crust into a 9-inch pie plate, crimp the edges, and chill the crust for 10 to 15 minutes.
• Line the crust with parchment or foil and fill with pie weights or dry beans. Bake 12 to 14 minutes. Remove weights and parchment, then bake 5 to 7 minutes more, just until the bottom looks set.
• (Optional) Brush the warm crust lightly with egg white. Reduce oven temperature to 325°F.
• In a large bowl, whisk the eggs, sugar, flour (or cornstarch), and salt until smooth.
• Warm the milk and cream in a saucepan over medium heat until hot and steamy (do not boil).
• Temper the eggs by slowly whisking about ½ cup of warm milk into the egg mixture. Then slowly whisk in the remaining milk mixture. Stir in the vanilla.
• Strain the custard through a fine-mesh strainer, then pour into the warm crust. Sprinkle nutmeg on top.
• Bake 35 to 45 minutes, until the edges are set and the center still jiggles gently. Cool on a rack for 1 hour, then refrigerate at least 4 hours before slicing.

Notes

• Don’t overbake. The center should still wobble slightly when you pull it from the oven.
• For extra insurance, check the center with a thermometer. 170°F to 175°F is a great target.
• Chill time matters. The custard firms up as it cools, so plan ahead for clean slices.